hartage
Well-known member
You seem to have misunderstood me.
I'm not attacking you or anyone else to using money. In the present system we have set up it's pretty difficult to live without it.
I'm just saying that money isn't something I'd include in the kind of world I want to live in, or the one I want to help build.
I don't think it's hypocritical to use money and think it's bad. I think a lot of us make compromises on the way we live our lives in order to get things done and/or avoid jail, stay warm, etc. It comes from having a difference of opinion from the bulk of people in the world about the way we should be doing things.
I agree with you, all money is is someone's word and nothing else. But therein lies the problem. People don't always keep their words, and it's not always your fault when it becomes problematic for you.
Have you seen whats happening with foreclosures in this country? How snake-oil salesmen have tricked people into these adjustable mortgage rates, causing them to lose their homes, thereby causing windows to be boarded up and driving down the property values of other peoples homes, causing more foreclosures and rampant homelessness? This can't happen in a system where we don't use money.
When you replace food, clothing, shiny things, whatever with little slips of paper that represent them, it opens up all these possibilities for how those slips of paper are handled, and used by certain individuals to accumulate massive amounts of wealth for themselves while leaving other people painfully poor. It creates the kind of fucked-up caste system where the top 1% controls 95% of the wealth. Where a CEO earns 350 times what a blue-collar worker does.
So don't tell me money is "practical". It's convenient hanging around in your pocket, waiting to be traded for your pack of cigarettes or new coat, perhaps, but not when it's helping to enslave you and further generations.
I don't totally disagree with you. The top 1% really does control just about everything. There are issues there but the problem is not in money itself. It's in the laws that govern accumulation of money. Kind of like a dam blocking a river. Don't blame the water, blame the regulation of that water, the dam, for problems.
On the other side I don't totally agree with you either. On enslavement.... I've seen a person go from dad died, mom goes nuts so he gets a foster home. From nothing he puts himself through school with loans. Gets his shit together with a degree in accounting and now has a nice life. Homeowner, and everything. So it can be done. Enslavement isn't totally external. A good part of enslavement is from internal reasons. (our own fuckups)
The barter system. Lets say YOU have a job working at a fast food joint. Will you barter burgers as trade for your labor ? Now you have 30 burgers. Tomorrow you'll have 60 burgers. By the end of the week you'll have 150 burgers. Now what ? Are you gonna haul around 150 burgers looking for a place that wants to take burgers for something YOU need ? Burgers are heavy, gets cold (looses value) and quickly rots (really looses value). Money just sits there untill you're ready to convert it to whatever you need. That is pretty damned practical. There is damned good reason why we left the barter system behind.
If the barter system is infinitely better, we would still be using it today.