bike trailer or panniers? | Squat the Planet

bike trailer or panniers?

Matt Derrick

Retired Wanderer
Staff member
Joined
Aug 4, 2006
Messages
10,542
Reaction score
13,815
Location
Portland, OR
Website
youtube.com
Hey folks, just wanted to get everyone's opinion on bike trailers vs panniers. i'm gearing up for a west coast tour this spring, and while I'm mostly leaning towards panniers, i'd like to get your opinions on which you like better and why? thanks!
 
  • Like
Reactions: ByronMc

Odin

ANTISOLIPSIST
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
2,401
Reaction score
2,931
Location
Earth
Website
www.youtube.com
I like the look of a compact setup with panniers. Towing a trailer would seem to be more cumbersome in turns and where you can go. Off road.... or whatever. Just from the look of it... but I don't know.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ByronMc
D

Deleted member 20

Guest
Trailer equals more. More energy required to pull it, more money to buy it, more maintenance (ie more flats) & more room for more junk. Keep it simple. You may have times where you want to take your bike on public transpo like a bus, subway, ferry where havin a trailer may prevent it or be too much of a pain.
 

Matt Derrick

Retired Wanderer
Staff member
Joined
Aug 4, 2006
Messages
10,542
Reaction score
13,815
Location
Portland, OR
Website
youtube.com
I've used both panniers and a bike trailer in previous trips, and the reason i'm leaning towards panniers is because they can be easily taken off the bike and brought inside if i'm staying at someone's house, or in similar situations. having a trailer was nice in terms of getting weight directly off the bike, but i did get a few flats on it and it's was a little bit unwieldly in certain situations.

again, i'm about 80% leaning towards panniers, especially since my bike came with front panniers and racks, but i just wanted to see what others thought. if someone has a good argument for the trailer, i'd like to hear it :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: tobepxt and ByronMc
A

Arapala

Guest
Exactly, i highly suggest using as little weight as possible. Panniers are the way to go. Even make a rear pannier set that transforms into a, hiking back pack. Think its 40L. You should be able to fit all your gear in that.
 

kecleon

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 29, 2013
Messages
216
Reaction score
293
Location
EU
You can get this bag that fits in the empty bit of the frame on a bike, like where the enginw would go if it was a motorcycle. Looks sick and good use of wasted space. I'd get that and strap a backpack to one of those rear rack things so I can carry it round if I leave the bike. I can't imagine ever towing a trailer. Its like these people I see with sidecars ruining the point of a motorcycle. You're losing all the good stuff and adding bad.

I can see it if you needed to move something really heavy or bulky and only had a bike but otherwise no.
 

ByronMc

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 22, 2012
Messages
425
Reaction score
275
Location
Richmond
Website
www.facebook.com
00R0R_7Pf79V8w1C0_600x450.jpg
 

Joni

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 8, 2013
Messages
176
Reaction score
248
i totally vote trailer but i am a bit bias :p as i ride recumbent these days and there is not very much room or attachment points for a rack. plus i can just throw my pack on it or what ever i find need then i am off without a fuss. gotta love a flatbed trailer for that. if you get the kids trailer it comes with builtin dry storage areas. :D


jand racks are awesome but there wieght limit is a bit low. max weight listed is 75lbs for the heavyist duty. http://www.jandd.com/search_results.asp?txtsearchParamCat=3&iLevel=2&subcat=13

trailer i have has 100lbs capacity. http://www.modernbike.com/itemgroup.asp?igpk=2126177534&TID=367&gclid=CPOzsZyf17sCFcVFMgodmyAAew but is a getto version of said burley brand.

hope this helps...
-joni
 

Odin

ANTISOLIPSIST
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
2,401
Reaction score
2,931
Location
Earth
Website
www.youtube.com
okay I see those advantages... and a trike looks so nice to ride.... but doesn't a trike severely curtail where you can ride? road/trail wise?.... ... I assume... assume being the key... that any cross country trip... (what Id like to do)... would have to factor in the contingency of dirt/gravel roads....

That is a very open question... but I suppose from a bike stealth camping view... It seems to me that trike touring would cause more difficulties.
but... those are just my open thoughts... experience is a better teacher.

and on a basic level... I like the look of a trike...

they are sexy looking machines... :p

but so are streamlined touring bikes...

damn... :D
 

Joni

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 8, 2013
Messages
176
Reaction score
248
okay I see those advantages... and a trike looks so nice to ride.... but doesn't a trike severely curtail where you can ride? road/trail wise?.... ... I assume... assume being the key... that any cross country trip... (what Id like to do)... would have to factor in the contingency of dirt/gravel roads....

That is a very open question... but I suppose from a bike stealth camping view... It seems to me that trike touring would cause more difficulties.
but... those are just my open thoughts... experience is a better teacher.

and on a basic level... I like the look of a trike...

they are sexy looking machines... :p

but so are streamlined touring bikes...

damn... :D
dirt roads... meh no problem...hybrid tires rock that.... kick it into low gear grab a snack and keep peddling :D it works even on a dirt road with an insane grade with a friend in tow cuz they don't have the gears kinda thing.... all be it at like 2mph :/ but your still movin :) oh! depends on the trike... they make full suspension downhill ones to speed record road ones to tour your butt off ones... they're not grandmas bike anymore :D it all depends on what your going for...

as far as riding a trike and touring with it stealth camping. so far i haven't ran into any problems. worst case scenario is i have to break it down flat and cover it with a camo tarp. riding one i have said for years is that its like riding in a snappy go-cart while sitting in a lawn chair reclined. it spreads a lot of the forces out across your whole body which makes it easier on some of us older folk ;D there is several downsides like you cannot bail while riding one, cars do not see you without a flag -.- and makes nap time way to easy. thats just to name a few. lol

as far as wherea trike fits... well i ride tadpole designs. most of the design these days are about the same wheel base length as a standard mountain bike. they have a width less than 4ft which is most sidewalks. going down a single track bike dirt path is probly not going to happen. i would just lock my stuff up and walk in if i had to do such a thing.

hope this helps...
-joni
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Odin
D

Deleted member 20

Guest
I would actually rather have a cargo bike than a trailer. Im a former messenger & they are great for large loads but not exactly light, inexpensive etc. I would still rather have somethimg like a surly big dummy than a trailer. Personal preference i guess since i have no intention of bringing a lot of stuff when bike touring. I currently dont have a touring bike just a couple fixed gear daily drivers. All this recent activity has got me thinking about buying a touring bike. If possible i am gomna buy a steel framed surly cross check or lht, ideally with racks & paniers, pedals, saddle, fendets etc. If you price out everything seperate these add ons are wicked expensive.
 

Matt Derrick

Retired Wanderer
Staff member
Joined
Aug 4, 2006
Messages
10,542
Reaction score
13,815
Location
Portland, OR
Website
youtube.com
  • Like
Reactions: ByronMc

About us

  • Squat the Planet is the world's largest social network for misfit travelers. Join our community of do-it-yourself nomads and learn how to explore the world by any means necessary.

    More Info

Help us pay the bills!

Total amount
$10.00
Goal
$100.00

Latest Library Uploads