Spreading anarchism -- or voluntarism

Joined
Dec 8, 2017
Threads
5
Messages
35
Likes
16
Current Location
richmond
Reactions
75% 7% 18%
#1
Undoubtedly, if you've ever debated -- virtually or in person -- a statist, you'd be well aware of the rigid, stubborn, non-arguments their full of.

1:
Who will build the roads!

Answer = the same damn people. A society having a perceived "authority" has nothing to do with roads being built. Yes the "government" pays the contractors, but where does that money come from?? Individuals! In the form of taxes

2:
Haveing "government" is a necessity. Without it there would be constant bloodshed and chaos!

Answer = flip threw a damn history book. Nearly all of the most atrocious acts of humanity against humanity was played out not by people breaking the law, but by those obeying and Enforcing those laws. Individuals don't incite wars on the Continental ( world stage )scale. Governments do


this non-argument comes from the idea that humans are inherently evil, untrustworthy, and malicious. The statist solution is as follows -- we'll take a subset of those evil, untrustworthy, and malicious humans, and give them permission AND our resources to forcibly enforce their biased opinions on how society should be structured

3:
I'm the absence of government, violent street gangs would rise to power, creating a brand new government!

Answer = no, no it wouldn't. ( triple negative, yeah I see that ) by definition a street gangs could never be considered government. The fundamental difference being the perceived "right to rule." Let's use a gang rape for example, seems appropriate. Even if 100% of the gang agrees that "yes it's been a long day and we're all going to have sex with you(rapee)" I'm absolutely positive that the rapee in 100% of these cases Never views their demands as legitimate. That's the difference between gangs and government, the perceptual legitimacy.

Just a few of their mental bootlicking talking points. There are many more though
 
Joined
Aug 27, 2017
Threads
23
Messages
208
Likes
159
Current Location
Slabs
Website
jerrellofearth.wordpress.com
Reactions
97% 1% 2%
#2
Don't worry about negatives. English is a Germanic language. A triple negative would technically correct the perceived problem a double negative supposedly causes? I forget, it's been a long time since I took a college English course, but I think the argument is two negatives equal a positive (math rule), so therefore a third negative would carry the initial negative.
Other than that, I like your post.:)
 
Joined
Dec 21, 2017
Threads
2
Messages
18
Likes
9
Current Location
Pismo Beach
Reactions
76% 18% 6%
#3
So what is the form of governance your supporting? Volunteeristic anarchy?
 
OP
OP
Soulutions
Joined
Dec 8, 2017
Threads
5
Messages
35
Likes
16
Current Location
richmond
Reactions
75% 7% 18%
#4
Well, "government" is only an abstract is idea to begin with, and maybe not even a productive one at that. You can't point at anything in the lowest physical common denominator (across individual's reality) of persons and say "yep, that's government." So really, it's only a believe system, much like religion!

So if you'll take self-governance, I'll submit that for which "system" I advocate.

Yes, Interchangeable with anarchy and also voluntarism
 

Similar threads

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 1)

Donate to StP!

Donations go towards paying our monthly server fees, adding new features to the website, and occasionally putting a burrito in Matt's mouth.

Total amount
$20.00
Goal
$50.00

Latest Status Updates

Fuck that feeling you lost your keys
Anyone considered going to Florida for some relief work? The money seems almost too good to pass up.
Day old bread from bakery, stolen rotisserie chicken, garbage-picked BBQ sauce from McD's, and yummy, peppery wild nasturtium! Fancy bum sammy.
In Austin... Starting to think we should have stayed in Dallas a day or 2 longer... At least there was bbq and a couch
Fate is a strange mistress, indeed.
After a sweet week in the slabs, layin' back, watchin the waves, on the beach carlsbad.
Finally got out of Willows. One ride to Williams. Next ride to Willits. Where there's a 'Will', there's a ...Jay?
I entered into the stock market a few days ago. It's basically "dancing money". You gotta see it to believe it.
Flying to Portugal tomorrow! Fuck yeah.

Forum Statistics

Threads
22,403
Messages
206,467
Members
13,289
Threads in last 24 hours
9
Messages in last 24 hours
54
Members in last 30 days
869
Latest member
beyondthepaleogender