Open Carry of Fixed Blades and 'Lawful Purpose' Clauses (1 Viewer)

nomad89

Newbie
Joined
Mar 11, 2013
Messages
59
Current Location
Baltimore, MD
Ok, before people send links to other threads I have done EXTENSIVE research both on this site and elsewhere about the legality of open carry of large knives.

I am aware that most states do not place restrictions on length for fixed blade knives carried openly as long as the blade is question is not a 'dirk, dagger, or stiletto' eg. a knife used for stabbing

The tricky part is how vague some of these laws are. For example Pennsylvania case law states that knives carried on one's person must have a 'common lawful purpose' which I feel is painfully subjective.
http://knife-expert.com/pa.txt

D.C. also places restrictions on knives without 'utility uses'
http://www.knifeup.com/knife-laws-in-washington-d-c/

I mean you could compare two very different knives such as a USMC Ka-Bar and a Mora or other similar camp knife. Most would consider both to be 'survival' knives with lawful or utility uses but under the framework of a law like that does a Ka-Bar have 'common lawful purpose' if it is only used lawfully or would it be illegal because it is a 'combat knife'? Really confused about what and what is not ok in areas with vague laws if anybody has personal any personal experience or can shed some light on the subject I would really appreciate it.
 
We sell all kinds of other stuff in our Etsy store!

Wolfs Paw

Newbie
Joined
Mar 24, 2014
Messages
43
Age
29
Current Location
Philladelphia
knives are illegal in NYC... just saying i had my hobo tool stolen by cops after being threatened. Wonder if i shoulda acted stupid and walked away and then defended myself and property if they tried to roll me lol PA - blade must be manual open and close with a locking mechanism and blade must not be more than the width of your palm. between thumb and index finger <--------> half way below pinky finger.
 
Last edited:

Wolfs Paw

Newbie
Joined
Mar 24, 2014
Messages
43
Age
29
Current Location
Philladelphia
Ok, before people send links to other threads I have done EXTENSIVE research both on this site and elsewhere about the legality of open carry of large knives.

I am aware that most states do not place restrictions on length for fixed blade knives carried openly as long as the blade is question is not a 'dirk, dagger, or stiletto' eg. a knife used for stabbing

The tricky part is how vague some of these laws are. For example Pennsylvania case law states that knives carried on one's person must have a 'common lawful purpose' which I feel is painfully subjective.
http://knife-expert.com/pa.txt

D.C. also places restrictions on knives without 'utility uses'
http://www.knifeup.com/knife-laws-in-washington-d-c/

I mean you could compare two very different knives such as a USMC Ka-Bar and a Mora or other similar camp knife. Most would consider both to be 'survival' knives with lawful or utility uses but under the framework of a law like that does a Ka-Bar have 'common lawful purpose' if it is only used lawfully or would it be illegal because it is a 'combat knife'? Really confused about what and what is not ok in areas with vague laws if anybody has personal any personal experience or can shed some light on the subject I would really appreciate it.

to choose your state or another click here http://www.knifeup.com/knife-laws/
 
OP
nomad89

nomad89

Newbie
Joined
Mar 11, 2013
Messages
59
Current Location
Baltimore, MD
Yeah I think in NY, at least according to the page on that site, fixed blades and un-assisted folding knives are legal as long as they are not intend to be used unlawfully against another person. As far as I can tell NY state does not place restrictions on blade length but that NYC's local ordinance limits blades to 4".

"Matter of Jamie D., 59 NY2d 589 (1983). Whether a “knife” is a “dangerous” knife may be determined on the basis of three alternative considerations: one, its own characteristics which show that it is primarily intended for use as a weapon; second, a modification, which converts what would otherwise be a utensil into a weapon; and third, the circumstances of the possession which may reveal that the possessor considers it a weapon and not a utilitarian tool."
http://tgace.com/2012/04/12/ny-knife-law/

My question more or less concerns the style of knife. For instance a KA-Bar by design is "primarily intended for use as a weapon" but could also be considered a utilitarian tool. I suppose a better question would be are combat knives legal as long as they are strictly used for utility purpose or if they would always be considered illegal inherently by it's design for use in combat? Perhaps with the clause that states if the "possessor considers it a weapon and not a utilitarian tool" would answer the question but maybe it would be at the discretion of the cops or a jury.

It's all quite confusing. I get the feeling that most states leave their laws intentionally vague to allow prosecutors free reign to put people away for blades that aren't specifically banned.
 

Wolfs Paw

Newbie
Joined
Mar 24, 2014
Messages
43
Age
29
Current Location
Philladelphia
Yeah I think in NY, at least according to the page on that site, fixed blades and un-assisted folding knives are legal as long as they are not intend to be used unlawfully against another person. As far as I can tell NY state does not place restrictions on blade length but that NYC's local ordinance limits blades to 4".

"Matter of Jamie D., 59 NY2d 589 (1983). Whether a “knife” is a “dangerous” knife may be determined on the basis of three alternative considerations: one, its own characteristics which show that it is primarily intended for use as a weapon; second, a modification, which converts what would otherwise be a utensil into a weapon; and third, the circumstances of the possession which may reveal that the possessor considers it a weapon and not a utilitarian tool."
http://tgace.com/2012/04/12/ny-knife-law/

My question more or less concerns the style of knife. For instance a KA-Bar by design is "primarily intended for use as a weapon" but could also be considered a utilitarian tool. I suppose a better question would be are combat knives legal as long as they are strictly used for utility purpose or if they would always be considered illegal inherently by it's design for use in combat? Perhaps with the clause that states if the "possessor considers it a weapon and not a utilitarian tool" would answer the question but maybe it would be at the discretion of the cops or a jury.

It's all quite confusing. I get the feeling that most states leave their laws intentionally vague to allow prosecutors free reign to put people away for blades that aren't specifically banned.
This is what was illegally seized from me in NYC - http://www.walmart.com/ip/Ozark-Trail-Hobo-Tool/19718066 ... Weapon? Think not! It's a full compact eating utensil...
 
OP
nomad89

nomad89

Newbie
Joined
Mar 11, 2013
Messages
59
Current Location
Baltimore, MD
I used to have one of those! Pretty sure it was the exact same brand and everything.

Sucks they confiscated it, fucking pigs.
 
OP
nomad89

nomad89

Newbie
Joined
Mar 11, 2013
Messages
59
Current Location
Baltimore, MD
I could see that. If memory serves me right I got mine when this trustifarian kid left it at this house I was staying at. Funny that it retails for only $4, I thought it was part of some sort of fancy yuppie mess kit or something.
 

Ridire

Lurker
Joined
Mar 27, 2014
Messages
32
Current Location
Providence
Any word on seaxes or langseaxes, or short swords? I have a straight 3 inch knife I use for religious purposes and replacing a large seax I use for woodwork and general utility. Both have a sheath.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 1)

About us

  • Squat the Planet is the world's largest social network for misfit travelers. Join our community of do-it-yourself nomads and learn how to explore the world by any means necessary.

    More Info

Support StP!

Donations go towards paying our monthly server fees, adding new features to the website, and occasionally putting a burrito in Matt's mouth.

Total amount
$40.00
Goal
$100.00

Monthly Goals

  1. Paying the Bills
    $40.00 of $50.00
    The first $50 in donations go towards paying our monthly server fees and adding new features to the website. Once this goal is reached, we'll see about feeding Matt that burrito.
  2. Buy Matt a Beer
    $40.00 of $75.00
    Now that we have the bills paid for this month, let's give Matt a hearty thank you by buying him a drink for all the hard work he's done for StP. Hopefully his will help keep him from going insane after a long day of squishing website bugs.
  3. Feed Matt a Burrito
    $40.00 of $100.00
    Now that the bills are paid and Matt has a beer in his hand, how about showing him your love by rewarding all his hard work with a big fat burrito to put in his mouth. This will keep him alive while programming new features for the website.
  4. Finance the Shopping Cart
    $40.00 of $200.00
    Now that the bills are paid and Matt is fed, perhaps it's time to start planning for those twilight years under the bridge... if only he had that golden shopping cart all the oogles are bragging about these days.

Latest Status Updates

I got my first trespass in over five years of riding, but the bull in clovis was doing that thing were he scans the cars from a ladder and my bike had the back wheel off so i couldnt run. I caught the next train after he let me go.
The amarillo northyard hopout is trashed, can yall clean up after yourself. No wonder they put up all these new fences here.
just now saw yet another article of people talking photos of themselves and falling into a waterfall and being pummeled into drowning - why people why - i recall when i first heard something like this out at Silver Falls eas of Corvallis, I think it was 2012 or 2013, but it never ceases to amaze me that it happens so much all over the world
Hitched into Quebec City, got a free wristband to a music festival with The Offspring and Blink-182 playing!! Good times, now off to Charny, back on the rails!
'All I know is that I dont know nothin'
Fillmore, California... California is the ultimate shithole..!!!
how many of you get inspired when you watch 'into the wild'??? i know it always makes me want to hit the road.
Faceplant wrote on NotmybestNotmyworst's profile.
Come here, let me give you a big, loving hug. But don’t pick up the soap.
Looking for folks in Nyc, tips also welcome!

Members online